Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration

Location
Des Moines, Iowa
Year
2006
Size
700 SF

Client
Drake University

Project Team
Tim Hickman
Paul Mankins

Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration – Substance Architecture
Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration – Substance Architecture

Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration

Designed by internationally famous architect Eero Saarinen, the Oreon E. Scott Chapel was dedicated in 1955 as part of Drake University’s former Divinity School. The Drake University campus was master planned by Eero and his father Eliel Saarinen in the 1940s and the chapel is one of nine buildings Saarinen designed on the campus. In more recent years the relentless march of time began to shadow its luminance, revealing signs of decay and the urgent need for restoration. In 2004, the Iowa Chapter of the American Institute of Architects honored the structure as one of Iowa’s 50 most significant buildings of the 20th century.

To celebrate the significance of this landmark project on its fiftieth anniversary, Substance Architecture championed the efforts to restore the Chapel to its original crisp beauty and address the pressing issues of maintaining the building’s integrity. Committed to restoring its original splendor without altering its historic essence, the team dove deep into the original construction blueprints. They undertook meticulous repairs, ensuring each detail mirrored Saarinen’s original vision. The leaking skylight, a significant concern, was rejuvenated, casting the chapel’s interior in its intended ethereal glow. This mission was made possible by the generous support of the Kruidenier Charitable Foundation and ensures that future generations can stand in the Chapel's light, appreciating the confluence of history, art, and architecture.

Collaborative Endeavor

Engaging in this restoration wasn't just a solitary endeavor by Substance. Collaboration was key. Working hand-in-hand with the University, we navigated the process of securing funding, emphasizing the importance of the project to potential donors. Once the necessary funding was secured, Substance helped prioritize and schedule the restoration, developed comprehensive construction documentation, and oversaw the construction process.

Preserving Iowa’s Architectural Heritage

Substance led this project pro bono, illustrating our unwavering devotion to the architectural history of the Midwest, especially the influential mid-20th century designs. It wasn’t just about refurbishing a structure; it was about honoring an era and its creators, and ensuring the chapel's legacy thrives.

Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration – Substance Architecture

Exploded axonometric diagram

Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration – Substance Architecture

Plan and section diagrams

Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration – Substance Architecture

Eero Saarinen

Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration – Substance Architecture

Building model 

“It doesn’t look like it was touched. It was a significant piece of historical architecture to begin with and the renovation feels entirely original. This inspiring attempt is what a restoration is supposed to be."

Juror Comment, Contract Magazine's 29th Annual Interiors Award Program

Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration – Substance Architecture

Original rendering

Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration – Substance Architecture

Vintage photo

Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration – Substance Architecture

Vintage photo

The Intricacies of Historical Restoration

Restoring the iconic Oreon E. Scott Chapel, a masterpiece of Eero Saarinen, was no small feat. Beyond its inherent architectural challenges, the project demanded meticulous attention to historical authenticity and preservation standards. The Substance team seamlessly orchestrated a blend of modern engineering with respect for the chapel's original essence, adeptly navigated the maze of preservation guidelines, and secured necessary endorsements. This project didn't just demonstrate Substance’s architectural prowess but also showcased our profound understanding of marrying history with modernity.

Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration – Substance Architecture

Invoice for custom furniture

Drake University Oreon E. Scott Memorial Chapel Restoration – Substance Architecture

Original plan drawing

Consultants

Skylight Restoration
Architectural Wall Systems
General Contractor
Crose & Lemke Construction

Awards

2012 Design Award, Religious Architecture-Restoration
Faith & Form Magazine/IFRAA
2008 Interior Award for Restoration
Contract Magazine’s 29th Annual Interior Awards Program
2007 Excellence in Historic Preservation
City of Des Moines
2007 Honor Award in Restoration
American Institute of Architects, Iowa Chapter

Publications

Winter 2012 Faith & Form
March 2010 Architecture Minnesota
January 2008 Contract
07:262 Iowa Architect

Photography by Farshid Assassi/Assassi Productions